Recommended Practice based on International Guidelines
The medical certificate of cause of death should be transmitted to the civil registrar or the statistics agencies to be used for legal and statistical purposes. In some countries, the information in the medical certificate of cause of death (or information on cause of death) is submitted to the registrar directly, who in turn submits the MCCD or cause of death data to the statistics agency. Other countries use a bifurcated form, containing a section for legal information and a section for statistical (cause of death) information. With this type of form, the legal information is submitted to the registrar and the statistical (cause of death) information is submitted directly to the statistics agency. The MCCD should not be given to the family to bring to the civil registration agency, the family may fail to report to the civil registrar.
If the law obligates the certifier of cause of death to directly transmit an MCCD to the civil registrar and statistics agency, there are two policy objectives that are met.
First, the efficient transmission of information provides the necessary information, including cause of death, to the civil registrar and statistics agency without placing an additional burden on an intermediary, often a mourning family, to convey the medical certificate of cause of death to the registrar.
Second, certifiers of cause of death are less likely to modify sensitive cause of death information if fewer people have access to and knowledge of that potentially sensitive information.
Paraguay
Legal Analysis
Under the Law on Civil Registration, the Medical Certificate of Death is issued by the physician and provided to the family, who then presents it to the Civil Registry to complete the registration process. As shown in the 2024 Ministry of Public Health Manual on Norms and Procedures for Vital Events, the detachable portion of the certificate of death given to the family contains cause of death information.
The Public Health Code (Law No. 836/1980) assigns the Ministry of Health responsibility for the collection, processing, analysis, and publication of vital statistics (Article 143). In addition to cause of death information being provided to the civil registration agency, the Ministry of Health retains the medical certificate of cause of death, which is used in generation of vital statistics.